Back to halefamilytree.com

This page is a comparison of our information with the information at http://members.aol.com/haleroots/familytree.html After going through and organizing all their notes it appears they are following JOHN SR > JOSEPH > THOMAS > SAMUEL DEVINE HALE > LUTHER.
They are descendants of " THOMAS HALE and ELIZABETH DEVINE."

Unfortunately, not the line that we are following. Our line goes from JOHN SR > JOHN JR > LEVI SR > DAVIS HALE > JAMES MASTERS HALE > JAMES EARL HALE

A major discrepancy was in their listing of John Hale Jr. and Mary Willis's children, which are totally different than ours, except for Levi Sr. Then they have a huge breakdown for John W. Hale, (who is suppose to be the 8th child of John and Mary), but we do not have this info.
They have an extensive breakdown of Edward Hale, which they name as brother to John Sr.

Another discrepancy was the listing of Thomas Hale and Jane Armstrong's children. Our tree says that the ones listed are the children of the oldest son John Hale.

Generation 1 Generation 2 Generation 3 Generation 4 Generation 5 Generation 6 Generation 7
Children of
John Hale Sr. and Elizabeth		 Children Of
John Hale Jr. and Mary Willis		 Children of
Levi Sr. and Catharine Tucker		 Children of
Davis Hale and Francis Tilley		 Children of
James Masters. Hale and Emily Belle McCoy Hale		 Children of
James Earl Hale and
Emily Alice Winders		 Children of
Robert Lee Hale and Kathleen G. Hayden
    i.James Hale(b.1794)
m. Mary Ann "Polly" Winkler 		children of James Hale and
Mary Ann "Polly" Winkler
i.Elizabeth Hale(b.1814)
ii.Margaret Hale(b.1817)
m. Joseph Carter
iii. Catharine Hale b. 1820
+Henry Jones , m. 17 Jan 1841
iv .Selina Hale(b.1823)
m.Robert Baulwin
v.Mary Ann Hale(b.1825)
vi .Jane Hale(b.1828)
vii .Albert Hale(b.1831)
+Nancy Ann Curtis b. 1831 		   
   
   
   
Children of
Albert Hale and Nancy Curtis
b. 12 Apr 1831, d. 13 Feb 1879
+Nancy Ann Curtis b. 13 Dec 1831, d. 5 May 1907
-Mary Elizabeth Hale
-John Allen Hale b. 1852
-Martha A Hale b. 1855, d. 1932
-Ida Hale b. 1856, d. 1938
-James Hale b. 1857, d. 1 Mar 1939 		 
ii.Ephraim Hale(b.1796)
m. Rebecca Rogers b. 1800 		children of
Ephraim Hale & Rebecca Rogers
1. Mary b. 1822
2. William b 1824
m. Martha A Redmond on 8/31/1866
3. Telitha b.1832
4. John W b.1853
m. Bell Strictland
i. Jesse S. b 1888
5. Robert Baldwin. b 1854
m. Mary E. Mollie Rusher 7/1864
6. Rev. Ephraim M. Jr.
m Sarah E Brown on 1/1/1877

children of
Robert Baldwin. b 1854
and Mary E. Mollie Rusher 7/1864
i. Cora b 1886
ii. Cullie b. 1892
iii. Walter O b 1898
iv. Dora

children of
Rev. Ephraim and Sarah B Brown
b 9/13/1860
i. Eugene b 1877
m. Minnie E Norton- son b 5/6/1900
ii. male 1880
iii. female 1883

 
iii.Polly Hale(b.1800)
m. Henry Wilkerson 		     
iv.Jane Catherine Hale(b.1802)
m. David Brown 		     
v.Betsy (Elizabeth)Hale(b.1804)
m. Clabourne Coker(b.1802) 		children of
Betsy (Elizabeth)Hale(b.1804)
and. Clabourne Coker(b.1802)
-Catherine Coker b. 1836
-Edward Fayette Coker b. 1825
-Thomas Coker b. 1831
-James Wesley Coker b. 1842
-Dennis Coker b.1829
-Bernetta Coker b.1827
-Richard Preston Coker b. 1839 		   
vi.Alsi (Ailsey)Hale(b.1806)
m. William Winkler 		     
vii.Nancy Hale(b.1808)
m. James Masters

children of
Nancy and James Masters
See Nancy Hale and James Masters tree
i .ELIZABETH JANE MASTERS, b. 13 Oct 1827
ii.POLLY ANN MASTERS, b. 04 Nov 1830
iii.HENRY W. MASTERS, b. 08 Feb 1832
iv.SALLY D. MASTERS, b. Abt. 1834
v.AMANDA P. MASTERS, b. Abt. 1836, Indiana
vi.JOSEPH I. MASTERS, b. 10 Mar 1838
vii.JOHN H. MASTERS, b. 05 Aug 1840
viii.WILLIAM H. MASTERS, b. Abt. 1843, Indiana
ix.ISHAM F. MASTERS, b. Mar 1845, Indiana
x.WILLIS LEE MASTERS, b. 10 Jan 1847









viii.Emily Hale(b.1810)
m. Desix Lockhart(b. 1805)

children of
Amelia Emily Hale(b.1810)
and Desix Lockhart(b. 1805)
-Alfred Lockhart b. 13 Jan 1831, Spencer County, IN
-Alice "Alsey" Lockhart b. Abt 1832, IN
-Hannah Lockhart b. Abt 1838
-Harvey Lockhart b. 1838, KY
-Richard Lockhart b. Abt 1843

   
ix.Isham Hale(b.1812)
m. Elizabeth Taylor

children of
Isham and Elizabeth Taylor
1.. Levi Madison (12.21.1833-12.19.1865)
m. Nancy Emeline Tillman
2. Presley (10.14.1835-2.20.1903)
m. Mary J. Williams
3. Joseph (1836-1913)
m. Rebecca Williams
4. James (1839-?)
5.Ailsie(Alley)(1844-?)
m. Ketterjohn
6. Henry (1846-?)
m.Mary A.
7. John (1849-?)
m. Grey
8. William B (3.1854-?)
m.Alwilda Baker
9.Edna
10. Mary Jane
m. Jim Day
11. Rebecca
m. Barna Taylor 		children of
Levi Hale and Nancy E Tillman
i. Mary Elizabeth b. 1853
ii. Morris Austin b 1854
iii. Edna Malinda b. 1856
iv. Jesse M. b. 1859
v. Norman Baily b. 1861
vi. Levi Madison b. 1864
vii. Henrietta Lavesta b. 1865
viii.Isham b 1858
ix. Catherine b. 1860 		 

x.Davis Hale(b.1814)
m. Francis *Fanny* Tilley
(b.1818) m. 09 Jan 1835

 

 children of
Davis Hale and Francis Tilley
1.Ephraim Hale(b.1838 d. 1888) Sgt.?
m. Anna Crosley
m. Susan A. McCoy
i. Lucy b 1866 		   
2.Richard M. J. Hale(b.1840)
died in childhood? not on 1850census 		   
3.Isham Hale(b.1844)    
4.Lucinda Hashberger Hale(b.1847)
m. David Land Sampson 		children of
Lucinda H. Hale & David Land Sampson
i. John M
m. Mary Campbell 		 
5.Catherine Hale(b.1849)
m. William M Furgason 		   
6.Sylvestor Hale(b.1852)
died in childbirth? 		   

7.James Masters Hale(b.1855)
m. Jennie Springston
m. Emily Elizabeth *Belle*
McCoy(b.1860)

Children of
James M. Hale and Emily Belle McCoy Hale
1.Homer Hale b.
2.Clifford Hale b.1885
3.Viena Hale b.1889
4.James Earl Hale(b.1892)
m. Emily Alice Winders(b.1893)

Notes:
My sister has James and Jennie
m on 9/9/1875 with 2 children
1. Claude B b 1879
m. Iva A Farmer 7/1/1900
2. William Rosco (b 4/3/1885)
m. Nora Bolin

 
 
Children of
James Earl Hale(b.1892)
m. Emily Alice Winders(b.1893)
1.Hartley Hale Sr(b.1913)
m.Mary Evelyn Keach
2.Helen Prestella Hale(b.1915)
m.John Franklin Stiles
3.Charles Edward Hale Sr(b.1917)
m. Nellie?
4.Louise Hale(b.1919)
m.James Cardell Smith
5.William Roy Hale(b.1923)
Barbara Bodell
6.James Elmer Hale(b.1925)
m. Bertha ?
7.Robert Lee Hale(b.1928)
m. Kathleen Genevieve Hayden (b.1929)
8.Bettye Joyce Hale(b.1931)
m.James Marvin Payne
m.Charles Clem
m.Lewis Franklin Cook
9.Maybelle Imogene Hale(b.1933)
m. Elvis Lea Stearman
m. Julius Hill
10.John Vernon Hale(b.1936)
m. Shirley Jean Stiles
m. Wanda Marie Milliom Farmer
5.Charles W. Hale (b.
m. Lorena and Nellie 		 

xi.Levi Hale Jr.(b.1816)
m.Elizabeth Jones b. 1820
m. Martha Tuley b. 1819

Haleroots Notes
LEVI HALE (LEVI3, JOHN2, JOHN1)
Children of LEVI HALE and ELIZABETH JONES
i. FINLEY HALE b.1857
ii. SINTHY CATHERINE HALE b.1859
iii. DOW HALE b.1861

children of
Levi Hale Jr. and Elizabeth Jones
1.Finley(b.1857 d. 1898)
2.Cynthia C. (b. 1859)
m. John M. Pearson in 1886
i. Nora P. m. Trimble
3.Dow (b. 1861)
m. Sarah Ada Nix b.1864
i. Hallie 1891
ii. Betty 1894
iii. female child b. 1902
4. unnamed child who died 		   
   
Haleroots notes for Dow
DOW5 HALE (LEVI4, LEVI3, JOHN2, JOHN1)
DOW5 HALE b.1861
m. Sarah Nix
Children of
DOW HALE and SARAH NIX
i. HALLIE BLANCH HALE b.1891
ii. BETTIE BELL HALE b. 1894
m. Evan Moon
iii. ELSIE MARY HALE b.1902
m. Walter Duncan 		 
   

 

 

 

 

Our notes:
LEVI Sr(son of John Jr and Mary Willis)
and THOMAS (son of Joseph & Nancy Willis)
are first cousins of the same clan of Hales who
came to Mercer Co. KY in 1785 from
Botetourt Co. VA, where it appears
that John Hale Jr., Levi's father and
John Hale Sr., Levi's grandfather, both
served in the Revolution. The name Levi,
and the name Thomas, are used several
times in the family. I believe this mixup
of cousins and uncles is how the first entry
into the DAR made it's mistake, and it has
been compounded with each new applicant.

Children of
John Hale Jr and Mary Willis

i.Levi Hale Sr b. 1774
m. Catharine Tucker b. 1776

 


 
ii.Polly Hale
m Henry Wilkerson




iii.Thomas W. Hale




iv.Andrew Hale




v.Eliza Hale
m. Joel Purcel




vi.Nancy Hale
m. James Masters
m. B F Gore?
children of
Nancy Hale and James Masters
i. Elizabeth Jane Masters b. 13 Oct 1827
ii. Polly Ann Masters b. 04 Nov 1830
iii. Henry W. Masters b. 08 Feb 1832
iv. Sally D. Masters b. Abt. 1834
v. Amanda P. Masters b. Abt. 1836
vi. Joseph I. Masters b. 10 Mar 1838
vii. John H. Masters b. 05 Aug 1840
viii. William H. Masters b. Abt. 1843
ix. Isham F. Masters b. Mar 1845
x. Willis Lee Masters b. 10 Jan 1847



vii. Samuel Hale

viii.Joseph Hale






 

NOTE:

Haleroots has different children listed
as the children of John Hale Jr. and Mary Willis
i. LEVI HALE, b. 1774
ii. RHODA HALE, b. Bet. 1775 - 1790
iii. HANNAH HALE, b. 1776
iv. JOSEPH HALE, b. Bet. 1780 - 1785
m. Betsy Sinnet/Stinnet, child DUNLAP
v. REBECCA HALE, b. 1788,
vi. ABIGAIL HALE1, b. Bet. 1790
vii. CASSANDRA HALE, b. 1792
viii. JOHN W. HALE, b. 1798
m. Louisiana Badger


viii. JOHN W.3 HALE (JOHN2, JOHN1)
m (1) Louisiana Badger
m (2) Elizabeth Hatchett
Children of
JOHN HALE and LOUISIANA BADGER:
i. RHODA M. HALE b. 1822
ii. LEVI GIDEON HALE b. 1824
iii. JOSEPH WILLIS HALE b.1826
JOSEPH WILLIS4 (JOHN W.3, JOHN2, JOHN1)
 m. Sarah Woods
Children of
JOSEPH HALE and SARAH WOODS
i. BENJAMIN HALE b. 1851
ii. DUNLAP HALE, b.1854 (Haleroots has his tree #26) (also see son Joshua #31)
iii. ALEXANDER HALE b. 1853
iv. NARSIS HALE b. 1847
iv. FELIX HARVEY HALE b. 1829
FELIX HARVEY4 (JOHN W.3, JOHN2, JOHN1)
 m.(1) Lucy Jane Stanley
m. (2) Mary Elizabeth Wilson
m. (3) Mary F.
Children of
FELIX HALE and LUCY STANLEY
i. MARY F. HALE.
ii. REBECCA MARY HALE, b. 1870
m. Edward Joseph Reiss
iii. GEORGE ALLEN HALE b. 1858
iv. HARVEY HARRY HALE, b. 1861.
v. HULETT B. HALE b. 1863; d. 1892;
m. Sarah A Norvell
vi. PLEASANT C. HALE b. 1868 (Haleroots has his tree #27)(also see Rebecca #32)
v. SABRA JOSEPHINE HALE b. 1829
vi. JOHN HALE b. Bet. 1830 - 1835
vii. JOSHUA HALE b. 1836.
viii. LUKE ARMON HALE b.1837
m. Nancy Jane Sallee
(LUKE ARMON4(JOHN W.3, JOHN2, JOHN1)
Children of
LUKE HALE and NANCY SALLEE are:
i. TURNER BOOKER5 HALE b.1868 (Haleroots has his tree #28) (also see ID Hale #33)
ii. JEFFERSON DAVIS HALE b.1862 (Haleroots has his tree #29) (also see Bertha #34)
iii. MARY ALICE HALE b.1863
ix. BURFORD MCDONALD HALE b. 1839
x. MARY ANN HALE, b. 1842
m.(1) Dudley Taylor
m. (2) Willian E. Sallee
xi. ANDREW JACKSON HALE b. 1845.
xii. ELIZABETH M. HALE b. 1847
xiii. HEWLETT B. HALE b. 1834




John Hale Sr.
 According to Haleroots
she has these listed as the children
of JOHN HALE Sr and ELIZABETH

i. THOMAS HALE b. 1742
ii. WILLIAM HALE b. Bef. 1750, VA1;
(WILLIAMS Note: This William Hale
born before 1750 may be John Hale Sr.'s
brother, and children, Thomas, Edward and Jesse
listed for John Sr. may be William's. )
iii. JOHN HALE, JR. b. Abt. 1750
iv. JOSEPH HALE b. Bet. 1751 - 1753
v. MARY MARGARET "POLLY" HALE b. Abt. 1752
vi. EDWARD HALE b. Abt. 1756
vii. BENJAMIN HALE b. Abt. 1758
viii. ELIZABETH HALE1 b. Abt. 1761
ix. JOB HALE, LT. b. Abt. 1764
x. ABIGAIL HALE b. Abt. 1765
xi. JESSE HALE b. Abt. 1768
xii. HANNAH HALE b. Unknown

i. Thomas Hale
(b.1742)
m. Jane Armstrong		   i.Armstrong Hale
ii.Jane Hale
iii.Joseph Hale
iv.Mary Hale
v.Sarah Hale
vi.Jehu Hale
vii.Thomas Hale
viii.Betsy Hale 		Note:
History of Lower Ohio Valley--
Central Library Reference Book
Josiah Hale MD, a retired physician
of Owensboro, KY., born in Ohio
County, Kentucky, January 25, 1829.
His parents were CALEB and SALLY (HUFF) HALE, both natives of
Virginia, but came in childhood to
Kentucky, with their parents. Caleb Hale's father was ARMSTRONG HALE who was born in London, England, but came to America settling first in Virginia and in 1800 in Ohio County, Ky. He was a farmer all his life. Caleb Hale was also a cabinet maker. He was a Whig and took an interest in all public questions. He was Sheriff of Ohio County, where he passed his whole life.
Josiah Hale graduated from the University of Louisville in 1856. He began practice in Fordsville, Ky and later removed to Hartford Ky. until 1863, when he took a post graduate course in New York and then locate in Owensboro, Ky. Josiah Hale married Nancy Willis in Ohio County, Ky. in 1852. She died in 1862. In 1873, Josiah Hale married Emily McHenry, daughter of Judge John H. McHenry, of Hartford. Three children, Emma, and Bettie, deceased, and one living, Mary, who married J A Dean. 		 
   
   
   
   
 
 

i..John Hale (b.7/29/1765)

----------------------------

According to Haleroots
she has these listed as the children
of THOMAS HALE and JANE ARMSTRONG
i. JOHN HALE, b. July 29, 1765
ii. ARMSTRONG HALE
iii. JANE HALE
iv. JOSEPH HALE
v. MARY HALE
vi. SARAH HALE
vii. JEHU HALE
viii. THOMAS HALE
ix. BETSY HALE

According to our notes, we have these
listed as the children of John Hale (b.7/29/1765)


Notes from : Haleroots
>EDWARD2 HALE (JOHN1)
Children of
vi. EDWARD HALE and MARTHA PERDUE
i. MARY HALE b. 1805
ii. JESSE HALE
m. Margaret Watts
JESSE3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
Children of
JESSE HALE and MARGARET WATTS
i. JULIA HALE (Haleroots has her info #24)
ii. HAMILTON J. HALE
iii. EDWARD C. HALE
iv. MARTHA HALE
Unmarried
v. MARY HALE
m. David French
vi. EGLANTINE HALE
m. Henry W. Broderick
vii. NEWTONIA HALE
m. Erastis W. Charlton
iii. PHOEBE HALE
m. John McClangherty
iv. THOMAS HALE
THOMAS3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
Children of
THOMAS HALE and (MISS) LUCAS
i. CHARLES EDWARD HALE
ii. LORENZO D. HALE
iii. GREEN HALE
iv. THOMAS HALE
v. RALPH HALE
vi. PRISCILLA HALE
m. William H. French
vii. MARTHA HALE
m. (1) David T. Alvis
m. (2) William Shannon
viii. RHODA HALE
v. ISAIAH HALE
ISAIAH3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
Children of
ISAIAH HALE and MARGARET LUCAS
i. ERASTIS HALE, d. "at a young age".
ii. CHARLOTTE HALE
m. William Moser
iii. LOUISA HALE
m. Jacob Snidow
iv. JULIANA HALE
m. Wolf Crotching
v. VIRGINIA HALE
m. James Kinzie
vi. WILMOTH HALE
m. Andrew. Hare
Children of
ISAIAH HALE and SALLY HALL
vii. LIZZIE HALE
m. George Spangler
viii. SALLY L. HALE
m. J. Harvey Dunn
ix. LUTHER C. HALE
m. Alice Peck
vi. CHARLES HALE
m. Catherine Dunn
CHARLES3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
Children of
CHARLES HALE and CATHERINE DUNN
i. JOHN D. HALE.
ii. WILLIAM H. HALE.
iii. ISAAC HALE d. "at a young age".
iv. HULDA HALE
m. Andrew Fillinger
v. MARTHA HALE
m. John Walker
vii. ISAAC HALE
viii. DANIEL HALE
m. Elizabeth Watts
DANIEL3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
Children of
DANIEL HALE and ELIZABETH WATTS
i. THOMAS HALE
ii. CHARLES E. HALE
iii. JOHN A. HALE
iv. DANIEL F. HALE
v. ELIZABETH HALE
m. William Shumate
vi. PAULINE HALE
m. C. W. Tolley
vii. LINNIE HALE
m. R. G. Roland
viii. CORNELIA HALE
m. William Brown
ix. ELIAS HALE
m. Nancy Peters
ELIAS3 HALE (EDWARD2, JOHN1)
 Children of
ELIAS HALE and NANCY PETERS
i. JOHN E. HALE
m. (Miss) Moore
ii. CHARLES A. HALE
m. (Miss) Bailey
iii. RUFUS A. HALE
m. Julia Bailey
iv. CONRAD HALE
v. MARY HALE
m. CALVIN HARRY
vi. ADELIA HALE
m. JOHN T. CARR.
vii. JULIA HALE. Unmarried
x. WILLIAM HALE
m. (Miss) Williams

ix.JOB HALE and HANNAH OGLE
JOB2 HALE, LT. (JOHN1)
Children of
.JOB HALE and HANNAH OGLE
i. ISAAC HALE
ii. JOHNNY HALE
iii. BETSY HALE
iv. NANCY HALE
v. SALLY HALE

iv Joseph Hale
b. Bet. 1751 - 1753
m. Nancy Willis

 

i.Thomas Hale (b.1775)
m. Elizabeth Devine

-----------------------------------

Haleroots
has these listed as the children
of JOSEPH HALE and NANCY WILLIS
i. MARY HALE b. Abt. 1774
ii. NANCY HALE b. Bet. 1775 - 1784

iii. THOMAS HALE b. Bet. 1775 - 1784
THOMAS3 HALE (JOSEPH2, JOHN1)
Children of
THOMAS HALE and ELIZABETH DEVINE:
i. JOSEPH WILLIS HALE b. 1805
m. Mary Rice
JOSEPH WILLIS4 (THOMAS3, JOSEPH2, JOHN1)
Children of
JOSEPH HALE and MARY RICE
i. THOMAS S.5 HALE b.1829
ii. FRANCIS MARION HALE b.1831
iii. ABSOLOM HALE b.1832
iv. ELIZA HALE b.1838
v. BUCKNER HALE b.1841

ii. SAMUEL DEVINE HALE b. 1807
SAMUEL DEVINE4 (THOMAS3, JOSEPH2, JOHN1)
m. Elizabeth Rice
Children of
SAMUEL HALE and ELIZABETH RICE
i. ZELENDA HALE b. Abt. 18271
m. James Sadler
ii. VASHITA HALE b.1828
iii. THOMAS HALE b. Abt. 1830
m. Nancy J. Hatchett Farris
iv. SHELTON WALTER HALE b.1835
v. LUCY HALE b. 1836
m. Jacob Miller
vi. MARANDA HALE b.1838
m. John W. Burton
vii. LUTHER HALE b.1841
m. Catherine Stines
(Haleroots has his tree #30)
 (also see Samuel #35 and Walter #36)
viii. VICTORIA HALE b. Abt. 1843

iii. MARY "POLLY" HALE b. 1809
m. Jessie Hale Hungate
iv. ANDREW D. HALE b. 1810
m. Elizabeth Horn
v. THOMAS W. HALE b.1812
m. Mary "Polly" Burns
vi. GEORGE WASHINGTON HALE b. 1814
m. Rebecca Devine
vii. ELIZA HALE b. 1816
m. James Downey
viii. NANCY HALE b. 1817
m. Ebenezer B. Carey
ix. LEVI HALE b. 1819
m. (1) Millie Duncan
m. (2) Nancy


iv. HANNAH HALE b. Abt. 1778

i.Levi Hale (b.1821)

----------------------

    
Generation 1 Generation 2 Generation 3 Generation 4 Generation 5 Generation 6